If Peyton Manning plays for Pats and Tom Brady plays for Colts, which team will win the Superbowl th

Assume everything else stays the same... only QB switch...

If Peyton Manning plays for Pats and Tom Brady plays for Colts, which team will win the Superbowl this year?plays

Tom Brady with the Indianapolis Colts would definitely win the Superbowl. If the New England Patriots had Peyton Manning as the quarterback, he would be dealing with all new players, and I know for a fact, that Belichick and him would always fight, because of the way Belichick operates. Tom Brady is a great quarterback but that's all. The fact that he got another woman pregnant, and she had his baby, and then he's dating another woman says that he's not a guy who wants to settle down. He's not a family man like Brett Favre and Deanna and there 2 daughters. Now Brett Favre is the MAN--GO PACKERS GO ALL THE WAY TO THE SUPERBOWL.

If Peyton Manning plays for Pats and Tom Brady plays for Colts, which team will win the Superbowl this year?opera ticket opera theater

Patriots are the better team no matter who throws the ball
I think the Pats would still win. I think both teams would be worse off with the other quarterback.
the colts. mannnig couldnt play for a classless coach and orginazation so he'd quit
Manning couldn't exist in Bellicheck's system, because Manning calls his own plays, and ad-libs on the line (and Bellicheck is a control freak). Brady plays the role, that Manning couldn't ever do... now, that he's established.

The Packers are winning anyways, in Favre's last game. I saw this coming from a season-away... he'll beat one of these QBs, and you'll lose your money, as he does it.

Wait until you see the drama build, for the Cowboys %26amp; Saints %26amp; Detroit %26amp; the Giants.. and they go down, really easy (like Seattle last year). Everyone thinks the AFC has the keys to the Super Bowl -- and that's where the $$$ will be lost.
The thing is ea QB is significant for the team they're with. If they switch teams then the playing style would change, but either way the game would be close, giving it still to the Pats.
you know i never thought of that one , good question. i'll still say new england because of more good players !!!
I would never betray Emperor Belichick!
If Tome Brady had Harrison, Stokely, Wayne and Clark his whole career, he would have won 7 in a row.
The winner would be the The New Indianenglapolis Coltriots
The Patriots would win with Kellen Clemens at QB.
The colts. Tom Brady can do it anywhere, with anyone.
since u put it like that, i still don't like Manning so ill deff go with the colts....but in reality the pats the the best all around team....
Brady wins with any team he plays 4. including the sucky Raiders.
That's a good one. I'd have to go with Manning.
Everything else stays the same???? Manning and the Pats would win.

Why????? because Brady is an average qb that is over emphasized and inflated in ability in the system he plays in.

That is the one that Belechek has , Brady is a product of playing for the cheater. Manning is the better pure qb who can play anywhere with anyone. hence the other stars on the Patriots would just look that much better with a qb that would know how to use them. And not rely on the sidelines so much
Its still a coin toss.
Brady is highly over rated and is a product of a the system with good players around him. Manning is a much better QB.
Peyton Manning and the Patriots would win because I don't think Tom Brady would be good with any other team